SV_RFC2181_5_4_never_merge_RRs - Never merge RRs from response with RRs in cashe
Verify that a NUT never merges RRs from a response with RRs in the cache to RRset
- Servers must never merge RRs from a response with RRs in their cache
to form an RRSet. If a response contains data that would form an
RRSet with data in a server's cache the server must either ignore the
RRs in the response, or discard the entire RRSet currently in the
cache, as appropriate.
Caching Server
SV_RFC2181_5_4_never_merge_RRs.seq [-tooloption ...]: KOI tool option
See also DNSConfig.pm
- Network Topology
. domain org domain example.org domain
AP Server1 (TN) DNS Server2 DNS Server3 DNS Server4
|A.example.org |A.ROOT.NET |NS3.example.org |NS4.example.org
|3ffe:501:ffff:101::10 |3ffe:501:ffff:101::20 |3ffe:501:ffff:101::30 |3ffe:501:ffff:101::40 ,41
|192.168.1.10 |192.168.1.20 |192.168.1.30 |192.168.1.40,41
| | | |
Net-y --+--------+---------------+------------------------+------------------------+-- 3ffe:501:ffff:101::/64
| 192.168.1/24
|
|
Router (TN)
|3ffe:501:ffff:100::1
|192.168.0.1
|
|
|
Net-z --+--------+-----------------+-------- 3ffe:501:ffff:100::/64
| | 192.168.0/24
| |
DNS Server1 (NUT) DNS Client1 (TN)
3ffe:501:ffff:100::XXXX 3ffe:501:ffff:100::20
192.168.0.10 192.168.0.20
XXXX: EUI64
- Setup
- Set the DNS Server1's (NUT) address as above mentioned Network Topology.
- Configure the Server1's (NUT) zone file to response query from TN.
- Example of root server list:
- For IPv4:
. 3600000 IN NS A.ROOT.NET.
A.ROOT.NET. 3600000 A 192.168.1.20
- For IPv6:
. 3600000 IN NS A.ROOT.NET.
A.ROOT.NET. 3600000 AAAA 3ffe:501:ffff:101::20
- Example of example.com zone file:
$TTL 86400 ; TTL of 1 day
@ IN SOA NS1.example.com. root.example.com. (
2005081600 ; serial
3600 ; refresh every 1 hr
900 ; retry every 15 min
604800 ; expire after a week
3600 ; Minimum TTL of a 1 hr
)
;
IN NS NS1.example.com.
NS1 IN A 192.168.0.10
;
This test sequence is following.
<-------------- TN --------------->
DNS Client1 (TN) DNS Server1 (NUT) DNS Server2 DNS Server3 DNS Server4
| | | | |
|----------------------------->| | | |
| 1. Send standard query | | | |
| QNAME=A.example.org | | | |
| QTYPE=A | | | |
| | | | |
| |-------------------------------->| | |
| | 2. Recv standard query | | |
| | QNAME=A.example.org | | |
| | QTYPE=A | | |
| | | | |
| |<--------------------------------| | |
| | 3. Send standard query response | | |
| | QNAME=A.example.org | | |
| | QTYPE=A | | |
| | AUTHORITY Name=org | | |
| | AUTHORITY Name Server | | |
| | =NS3.example.org | | |
| | ADDITIONAL Name | | |
| | =NS3.example.org | | |
| | ADDITIONAL Address | | |
| | =192.168.1.30 | | |
| | | | |
| | v | |
| | | |
| |-------------------------------------------->| |
| | 4. Recv standard query | |
| | QNAME=A.example.org | |
| | QTYPE=A | |
| | | |
| |<--------------------------------------------| |
| | 5. Send standard query response | |
| | QNAME=A.example.org | |
| | QTYPE=A | |
| | AUTHORITY Name=example.org | |
| | AUTHORITY Name Server | |
| | = NS4.example.org | |
| | ADDITIONAL Name | |
| | = NS4.example.org | |
| | ADDITIONAL Address | |
| | = 192.168.1.40 | |
| | | |
| | v |
| | |
| |-------------------------------------------------------->|
| | 6. Send standard query |
| | QNAME=A.example.org |
| | QTYPE=A |
| | |
| |<--------------------------------------------------------|
| | 7. Send standard query response|
| | QNAME=A.example.org |
| | QTYPE=A |
| | ANSWER Name=A.example.org |
| | ANSWER Address=192.168.1.10 |
| | AUTHORITY Name=example.org |
| | AUTHORITY Name Server |
| | = NS4.example.org |
| | ADDITIONAL Name |
| | = NS4.example.org |
| | ADDITIONAL Address |
| | = 192.168.1.41 |
| | |
| | |
|<-----------------------------| |
| 8.Standard query response | |
| QNAME= A.example.org | |
| QTYPE=A | |
| ANSWER Name=A.example.org | |
| ANSWER Address=192.168.1.10 | |
| AUTHORITY Name=example.org | |
| AUTHORITY Name Server | |
| = NS4.example.org | |
| ADDITIONAL Name | |
| = NS4.example.org | |
| ADDITIONAL Address | |
| = 192.168.1.41 | |
| | |
|----------------------------->| |
| 9. Send standard query | |
| QNAME=NS4.example.org | |
| QTYPE=A | |
| | |
|<-----------------------------| |
|10.Standard query response | |
| QNAME=NS4.example.org | |
| QTYPE=A | |
| ANSWER Name=NS4.example.org | |
| ANSWER Address=192.168.1.40 | |
| or | |
| ANSWER Address=192.168.1.41 | |
| AUTHORITY Name=example.org | |
| AUTHORITY Name Server | |
| = NS4.example.org | |
| ADDITIONAL Name | |
| = NS4.example.org | |
| ADDITIONAL Address | |
| = 192.168.1.40 | |
| or | |
| = 192.168.1.41 | |
| | |
v v v
1. TN send standard query QNAME=A.example.org, QTYPE=A to NUT.
2. NUT transmits standard query to DNS Server2 (TN: root name server) (Judgment *2)
3. TN send query response to NUT w/ AUTHORITY Name=org, AUTHORITY Name Server=NS3.example.org.
4. NUT transmits standard query QNAME=A.example.org, QTYPE=A to DNS Server3 (TN: NS3.example.org) (Judgment *4)
5. TN send query response to NUT w/ AUTHORITY Name=example.org, AUTHORITY Name Server=NS4.example.org.
6. NUT transmits standard query QNAME=A.example.org, QTYPE=A to DNS Server4 (TN: NS4.example.org) (Judgment *6)
7. TN send query response to ANSWER Name=A.example.org, ANSWER Address=192.168.1.10.
8. NUT transmits query response to DNS Client1 (TN). (Judgment *8)
9. TN send standard query QNAME=NS4.example.org, QTYPE=A to NUT.
10. NUT transmits query response to DNS Client1 (TN). (Judgment *10)
- Packet Description
- 1st packet.
Standard query from DNS Client1 (TN) to Server1 (NUT)
|
IP Header |
Source Address |
CL1_NETZ |
Destination Address |
NUT_NETZ |
UDP Header |
Src Port |
2000 |
Dst Port |
53 |
DNS Header |
ID |
0x1000 |
QR |
0 |
OPCODE |
0 |
AA |
0 |
TC |
0 |
RD |
1 |
RA |
0 |
Z |
0 |
RCODE |
0 |
QDCOUNT |
1 |
ANCOUNT |
0 |
NSCOUNT |
0 |
ARCOUNT |
0 |
DNS Question section |
QNAME |
A.example.org |
QTYPE |
A (0x0001) |
QCLASS |
IN (0x0001) |
- 2nd packet.
Standard query from DNS Server1 (NUT) to Server2 (TN)
|
IP Header |
Source Address |
NUT_NETZ |
Destination Address |
SV2_NETY |
UDP Header |
Src Port |
ANY |
Dst Port |
53 |
DNS Header |
ID |
ANY |
QR |
0 |
OPCODE |
0 |
AA |
ANY |
TC |
0 |
RD |
0 |
RA |
ANY |
Z |
ANY |
RCODE |
ANY |
QDCOUNT |
1 |
ANCOUNT |
0 |
NSCOUNT |
0 |
ARCOUNT |
ANY |
DNS Question section |
QNAME |
A.example.org |
QTYPE |
A (0x0001) |
QCLASS |
IN (0x0001) |
- 3rd packet.
Standard query response from DNS Server2 (TN) to Server1 (NUT)
|
IP Header |
Source Address |
SV2_NETY |
Destination Address |
NUT_NETZ |
UDP Header |
Src Port |
53 |
Dst Port |
Value that NUT uses |
DNS Header |
ID |
Value that NUT uses |
QR |
1 |
OPCODE |
0 |
AA |
0 |
TC |
0 |
RD |
0 |
RA |
0 |
Z |
0 |
RCODE |
0 |
QDCOUNT |
1 |
ANCOUNT |
0 |
NSCOUNT |
1 |
ARCOUNT |
1 |
DNS Question section |
QNAME |
A.example.org
|
QTYPE |
A (0x0001) |
QCLASS |
IN (0x0001) |
DNS Authority section |
NAME |
org (Pointer 0xC016) |
TYPE |
NS (0x0002) |
CLASS |
IN (0x0001) |
TTL |
1 day (86400) |
RDLENGTH |
6 |
NSDNAME |
NS3.example.org (NS3 + Pointer 0xC00E) |
DNS Additional section |
NAME |
NS3.example.org (Pointer 0xC02B) |
TYPE
|
A (0x0001) |
CLASS |
IN (0x0001) |
TTL |
1 day (86400) |
RDLENGTH |
4 |
ADDRESS |
192.168.1.30 |
- 4th packet.
Standard query from DNS Server1 (NUT) to Server3 (TN)
|
IP Header |
Source Address |
NUT_NETZ |
Destination Address |
SV3_NETY |
UDP Header |
Src Port |
ANY |
Dst Port |
53 |
DNS Header |
ID |
ANY |
QR |
0 |
OPCODE |
0 |
AA |
ANY |
TC |
0 |
RD |
0 |
RA |
ANY |
Z |
ANY |
RCODE |
ANY |
QDCOUNT |
1 |
ANCOUNT |
0 |
NSCOUNT |
0 |
ARCOUNT |
ANY |
DNS Question section |
QNAME |
A.example.org |
QTYPE |
A (0x0001) |
QCLASS |
IN (0x0001) |
- 5th packet.
Standard query response from DNS Server3 (TN) to Server1 (NUT)
|
IP Header |
Source Address |
SV3_NETY |
Destination Address |
NUT_NETZ |
UDP Header |
Src Port |
Value that NUT uses |
Dst Port |
53 |
DNS Header |
ID |
Value that NUT uses |
QR |
1 |
OPCODE |
0 |
AA |
0 |
TC |
0 |
RD |
0 |
RA |
0 |
Z |
0 |
RCODE |
0 |
QDCOUNT |
1 |
ANCOUNT |
0 |
NSCOUNT |
1 |
ARCOUNT |
1 |
DNS Question section |
QNAME |
A.example.org
|
QTYPE |
A (0x0001) |
QCLASS |
IN (0x0001) |
DNS Authority section |
NAME |
example.org (Pointer 0xC00E) |
TYPE |
NS (0x0002) |
CLASS |
IN (0x0001) |
TTL |
1 day (86400) |
RDLENGTH |
6 |
NSDNAME |
NS4.example.org (NS4 + Pointer 0xC00E) |
DNS Additional section |
NAME |
NS4.example.org (Pointer 0xC02B) |
TYPE
|
A (0x0001) |
CLASS |
IN (0x0001) |
TTL |
1 day (86400) |
RDLENGTH |
4 |
ADDRESS |
192.168.1.40 |
- 6th packet.
Standard query from DNS Server1 (NUT) to Server4 (TN)
|
IP Header |
Source Address |
NUT_NETZ |
Destination Address |
SV4_NETY |
UDP Header |
Src Port |
ANY |
Dst Port |
53 |
DNS Header |
ID |
ANY |
QR |
0 |
OPCODE |
0 |
AA |
ANY |
TC |
0 |
RD |
0 |
RA |
ANY |
Z |
ANY |
RCODE |
ANY |
QDCOUNT |
1 |
ANCOUNT |
0 |
NSCOUNT |
0 |
ARCOUNT |
ANY |
DNS Question section |
QNAME |
A.example.org |
QTYPE |
A (0x0001) |
QCLASS |
IN (0x0001) |
- 7th packet.
Standard query response from DNS Server4 (TN) to Server1 (NUT)
|
IP Header |
Source Address |
SV4_NETY |
Destination Address |
NUT_NETZ |
UDP Header |
Src Port |
Value that NUT uses |
Dst Port |
53 |
DNS Header |
ID |
Value that NUT uses |
QR |
1 |
OPCODE |
0 |
AA |
1 |
TC |
0 |
RD |
0 |
RA |
1 |
Z |
0 |
RCODE |
0 |
QDCOUNT |
1 |
ANCOUNT |
1 |
NSCOUNT |
1 |
ARCOUNT |
1 |
DNS Question section |
QNAME |
A.example.org
|
QTYPE |
A (0x0001) |
QCLASS |
IN (0x0001) |
DNS Answer section |
NAME |
A.example.org (Pointer 0xC00C)
|
TYPE |
A (0x0001) |
CLASS |
IN (0x0001) |
TTL |
1 day (86400) |
RDLENGTH |
4 |
ADDRESS |
192.168.1.10 |
DNS Authority section |
NAME |
example.org (Pointer 0xC00E) |
TYPE |
NS (0x0002) |
CLASS |
IN (0x0001) |
TTL |
1 day (86400) |
RDLENGTH |
6 |
NSDNAME |
NS4.example.org (NS4 + Pointer 0xC00E) |
DNS Additional section |
NAME |
NS4.example.org (Pointer 0xC03B) |
TYPE
|
A (0x0001) |
CLASS |
IN (0x0001) |
TTL |
1 day (86400) |
RDLENGTH |
4 |
ADDRESS |
192.168.1.41 |
- 8th packet.
Standard query response from DNS Server1 (NUT) to Client1 (TN)
|
IP Header |
Source Address |
NUT_NETZ |
Destination Address |
CL1_NETZ |
UDP Header |
Src Port |
53 |
Dst Port |
2000 |
DNS Header |
ID |
0x1000 |
QR |
1 |
OPCODE |
0 |
AA |
0 |
TC |
0 |
RD |
1 |
RA |
1 |
Z |
0 |
RCODE |
0 |
QDCOUNT |
1 |
ANCOUNT |
1 |
NSCOUNT |
1 |
ARCOUNT |
1 |
DNS Question section |
QNAME |
A.example.org |
QTYPE |
A (0x0001) |
QCLASS |
IN (0x0001) |
DNS Answer section |
NAME |
A.example.org (Pointer 0xC00C)
|
TYPE |
A (0x0001) |
CLASS |
IN (0x0001) |
TTL |
1 day (86400) |
RDLENGTH |
4 |
ADDRESS |
192.168.1.10 |
DNS Authority section |
NAME |
example.org (Pointer 0xC00E) |
TYPE |
NS (0x0002) |
CLASS |
IN (0x0001) |
TTL |
1 day (86400) |
RDLENGTH |
6 |
NSDNAME |
NS4.example.org (NS4 + Pointer 0xC00E) |
DNS Additional section |
NAME |
NS4.example.org (Pointer 0xC03B) |
TYPE
|
A (0x0001) |
CLASS |
IN (0x0001) |
TTL |
1 day (86400) |
RDLENGTH |
4 |
ADDRESS |
192.168.1.41 |
- 9th packet.
Standard query from DNS Client1 (TN) to Server1 (NUT)
|
IP Header |
Source Address |
CL1_NETZ |
Destination Address |
NUT_NETZ |
UDP Header |
Src Port |
2000 |
Dst Port |
53 |
DNS Header |
ID |
0x1001 |
QR |
0 |
OPCODE |
0 |
AA |
0 |
TC |
0 |
RD |
1 |
RA |
0 |
Z |
0 |
RCODE |
0 |
QDCOUNT |
1 |
ANCOUNT |
0 |
NSCOUNT |
0 |
ARCOUNT |
0 |
DNS Question section |
QNAME |
NS4.example.org |
QTYPE |
A (0x0001) |
QCLASS |
IN (0x0001) |
- 10th packet.
Standard query response from DNS Server1 (NUT) to Client1 (TN)
|
IP Header |
Source Address |
NUT_NETZ |
Destination Address |
CL1_NETZ |
UDP Header |
Src Port |
53 |
Dst Port |
2000 |
DNS Header |
ID |
0x1001 |
QR |
1 |
OPCODE |
0 |
AA |
0 |
TC |
0 |
RD |
1 |
RA |
1 |
Z |
0 |
RCODE |
0 |
QDCOUNT |
1 |
ANCOUNT |
1 |
NSCOUNT |
1 |
ARCOUNT |
1 |
DNS Question section |
QNAME |
NS4.example.org |
QTYPE |
A (0x0001) |
QCLASS |
IN (0x0001) |
DNS Answer section |
NAME |
NS4.example.org (Pointer 0xC00C)
|
TYPE |
A (0x0001) |
CLASS |
IN (0x0001) |
TTL |
ANY |
RDLENGTH |
4 |
ADDRESS |
192.168.1.40 or 192.168.1.41 |
DNS Authority section |
NAME |
example.org (Pointer 0xC010) |
TYPE |
NS (0x0002) |
CLASS |
IN (0x0001) |
TTL |
ANY |
RDLENGTH |
6 |
NSDNAME |
NS4.example.org (Pointer 0xC00C) |
DNS Additional section |
NAME |
NS4.example.org (Pointer 0xC00C) |
TYPE
|
A (0x0001) |
CLASS |
IN (0x0001) |
TTL |
ANY |
RDLENGTH |
4 |
ADDRESS |
192.168.1.40 or 192.168.1.41 |
- Exp.
NUT_NETZ |
DNS Server1's (NUT) Net-z address |
CL1_NETZ |
DNS Client1's (TN) Net-z address |
SV2_NETY |
DNS Server2's (TN) Net-y address |
SV3_NETY |
DNS Server3's (TN) Net-y address |
SV4_NETY |
DNS Server4's (TN) Net-y address |
2. Received standard query including QNAME=A.example.org, QTYPE=A.
4. Received standard query including QNAME=A.example.org, QTYPE=A.
6. Received standard query including QNAME=A.example.org, QTYPE=A.
8. Received standard query response.
10. Received standard query response.
None
RFC2181 Clarifications to the DNS Specification
5.4. Receiving RRSets